Katy Perry‘s role as an American Idol judge has garnered attention for her critiques that have been compared to Simon Cowell, the original “mean” judge of the show. Katy Perry has faced backlash for what some viewers perceive as harsh comments and mom-shaming of contestants, drawing comparisons to Cowell’s biting rhetoric and persona, Fox News reported.
American Idol Judge Katy Perry Compared To Simon Cowell
However, the backlash against Perry may be more intense due to the rise of social media, allowing viewers to react in real-time and hold public figures more accountable. Additionally, Perry’s public persona as a colorful, playful, and fun artist contrasts with Cowell’s behind-the-scenes producer background and neutral fashion choices.
Katy Perry had a successful music career with numerous awards and platinum albums, including her groundbreaking album “Teenage Dream.” Nevertheless, her role as an American Idol judge has sparked controversy, with some viewers calling out her comments as bullying and mean-spirited.
On the other hand, supporters argue that Perry is just doing her job as a judge and providing honest feedback to contestants, similar to Cowell’s approach during the earlier seasons of the show.
As Kara Schmiemann, strategic communications director for public relations firm Red Banyan, pointed out, there may be a double standard when it comes to how male and female celebrities are scrutinized in the public eye.
READ ALSO: American Idol Auditions Katy Perry Faces Criticism For Condescending Behavior
Katy Perry and Simon Cowell’s Lasting Impressions
Perry’s playful and colorful persona may be at odds with the harsh criticisms she delivers as an American Idol judge, whereas Cowell’s biting persona was in line with his established brand as a tough judge. Nevertheless, both Perry and Cowell have made their mark on “American Idol” and left a lasting impression on viewers.
Overall, Katy Perry’s role as an American Idol judge has been compared to Simon Cowell for her critiques that some viewers perceive as harsh. While Perry’s public persona and successful music career contrast with Cowell’s background and fashion choices, both judges have faced scrutiny for their comments on the show. Whether or not Perry’s judgments are in line with Cowell’s legacy as a tough judge is a matter of opinion, but one thing is clear – the role of an American Idol judge is no easy task, and both Perry and Cowell have left their mark on the show.
READ ALSO: American Idol Auditions: Judges Heart-to-Heart With A Contestant
